"The Aristocrats" is Pretty Crass

aristocrats_poster.jpgAs we're sure you readers out there can tell, Bostonist is pretty sarcastic and can laugh at itself or anyone else for that matter. So when we heard about this movie, "The Aristocrats," which focuses on one dirty joke delivered by a slew of different comedians, we thought we should check it out. This hour-and-a-half documentary by Penn Jillette, of the comedy/magic act Penn and Teller, visits with comedians young and old to get their take on the standard joke, "The Aristocrats." Bostonist had never heard the Vaudeville era joke, so our precious little ears (and stomachs) were surprised to hear that the premise of the joke usually involves vomiting, incest, sex, and feces (not exactly in that order according to the many comedians). We admit that some parts were extremely funny (Sarah Silverman and Bob Saget) while other parts were just pretty gross. Bostonist can't recall the last time people walked out during a movie we went to, but it was pretty standard at "The Aristocrats," with some movie-goers leaving five minutes into the film. While the premise of a documentary about one joke and many comedians' variations on it is good, the film would have been better cut down to 45 minutes on HBO. While the New York Times and the Boston Globe both seemed to give it the thumbs up, Bostonist would tell you to save your $10 and rent it on Netflix.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@bostonist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • I thought the movie was really funny (and so did lots of other people)--the only reason to wait for the DVD is because it's bound to have hours of extra footage that they just didn't have room for.

  • Chris

    Out of idle curiosity, do we 'rent' things from netflix? I usually say I 'netflix' things. Rent from video stores, netflix from ... netflix.

    It's interesting how new lingoes get introduced. I didn't used to talk to friends about what was in my queue, after all.

  • I saw the film and enjoyed it. In talking with friends, we realized we missed seeing certain comics "take" on the joke, including Margaret Cho, Billy Crystal and Steve Sweeney.







    Gilbert Gottfried was hysterically funny with his old timey vaudeville delivery and expressions, and Kevin Pollack imitating Christopher Walken doing the joke was beyond belief. It's all... in the....pauses.







    Oh yeah, there was even a mime telling the joke, and I loathe mimes, but Bill the Mime was very good. I'm puzzled why people would walk out. What did they think they were going to see? I went to see "Hustle and Flow" a few weeks back, and a senior citizen couple asked me what it was about, at the ticket window. When I told them "pimps, whores and rap music," they opted for Willy Wonka's Choco experience. There's always choice, folks.

  • ed

    well, the movie IS billed as "obscene, disgusting, vulgar and vile." i wonder what people are expecting.

  • Katie

    Thanks for the heads up on the "flicks" vs. "flix" Eric.

  • Eric

    Netflix not Netflicks.

    Also I think that people exiting a film five minutes after it started reflects more on the quality of the people exiting rather than the quality of the film.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Tips

The day's most popular stories from Bostonist every evening in your inbox from our newsletter.

About Bostonist

Bostonist is a website about Boston. More

Editor: Matthew Gannon

Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

nice
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Bostonist.

All Our RSS