Whatever with Traffic Rules - We Like Mass. More Than Oregon

RoadSafety.jpg

The Herald ran an article today reporting that according to a study by the insurance agency GMAC (which is totally going to be Bostonist's new rap name), Massachusetts drivers rank second worst among the contiguous 48 states and D.C. in knowledge of traffic laws, while Oregon's are at the top (Rhode Island is at the bottom). However, Mass. has the lowest rate of fatal traffic accidents. The Herald, citing an unnamed state highway official, says the low death rate is a result of good emergency services and signage, but Bostonist has another idea: Following traffic laws too closely, to the exclusion of common sense, can be hazardous to your health.

As it happens, (this) Bostonist lived in Portland, Oregon, for four long years, and we can confirm that people in the Beaver State are punctilious in following the rules of the road. Drivers stop for yellow lights, pedestrians wait at the kerb for a walk sign even when no car is in sight, and good manners and patience generally prevail. All of which is almost too annoying for words. Traffic is a dynamic situation requiring quick wits and an intuitive understanding of what rules are worth upholding strictly. It is to the credit of Mass. drivers that when there is an obstruction in half of one lane, they know to swing slightly around it and trust that cars in neighboring lanes will swing to one side as well. Oregon drivers would line up behind the blockage and wait wait wait, signals blinking, while people in the neighboring lane cruised by obliviously. On the highways, Oregonians assume that since the speed limit is the fastest that anyone would ever go, it's OK to be in the left lane while driving the limit. Must we explain how wrong that is? And the pedestrians - dear god! Grown people waiting patiently on the corner for a light to tell them it's safe to cross an empty street, a painful sight. They were so dependent on Don't Walk signs that when one wasn't working, they were practically paralyzed with fear at the prospect of jaywalking. Not that they should have been - the drivers would routinely come to a screeching halt upon seeing a pedestrian set a single foot onto the street in anticipation of crossing.

Maybe the secret to the way we Mass. drivers cheat death is that our indifference to the law has made us more adaptable, able to recognize a cliff before we drive over it, while Oregonians simply see a green light and go, lemming-like, to whatever horrible fate the road holds. Also, while we're cracking on Oregon and talking about driving, they're not even allowed to pump their own gas.

Photo: The most boring game ever.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@bostonist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Grandpa Portlandist

    Bostonist Josh, this is your father calling ....

    It has been more than a decade since you left hearth and home for the Sodom and Gomorrah that is the East Coast. While there are still the few (the proud?) who stand at empty streets waiting for the Walk sign, they are the small minority.

    We now have all the joys of rude, crazed behavior that you cherish from your (de)formative years in NYC and the Athens of America (not in Georgia).

    And, technically, you lived in Portland for five long years: 8th through 12th grades (count 'em, 5), with your junior-year hiatus trying to die in Argentina included.

  • All goofy regional chauvinism aside, I'll concede that Mass. drivers maybe aren't the best and certainly aren't the most courteous, but I don't think they're so bad either. One thing I'm fully on board with, though, is that rotaries are just awful awful awful.

  • natis

    MA is the worst place I have ever driven. Most don't know how to handle right on red, the rotary is a stupid invention that few people understand the way it is supposed to work and when a road is newly paved and no lines have yet to be paved on it, people have no freaking clue where they should line up. The natives are effin' idiots.

  • Lisa

    Yes, I have to say, Bostonist is seriously rationalizing here! I moved to Boston from D.C., where I thought drivers were aggressive, and was horrified. I'm now back in D.C. and, yes, indeed, drivers are better here. Aggressive, but generally following basic rules of driver courtesy. I agree that standing at the corner when there are no cars for miles is pretty foolish, but there is something in between that and just crossing the road whenever and wherever the mood strikes. And I just don't buy that it's safer in Boston because drivers are so nuts. Literally, first day I'm driving into Boston, I get sideswiped by a small truck on the Expressway bc I foolishly thought he would let me merge into his lane. Anyway, I could go on and on...

  • Yeah, yeah, saying that lawless driving saves lives is pure hyperbole if not out-and-out disingenuity, but it's amusing.

  • Peter

    If you are able to argue that Massachusetts has fewer fatalities because of insane driver flagrantly violating the rule of the road, then you are officially able to rationalize anything. Speaking as a New Hampshire driver (we were 26 on the list), I urge the drivers of Massachusetts to keep their fatality levels low by staying in Massachusetts!

  • JohnnyBob

    "Maybe the secret to the way we Mass. drivers cheat death is that our indifference to the law has made us more adaptable...."



    Or, maybe it's because Mass. is a crowded maze, like a supermarket, and likely to have a hight rate of fender-benders as less fatalities. Oregon has those miles and miles of broad expanses, hours of Interstate and winding roads, punctuated by communities. Eight, Nine or more hours from Eastern Oregon to the coast. If we were pushy and rude like Mass. drivers, I suspect the death rate would rise.



    Also, just thought of this... could it be those numbers are inflated by the displaced Californians and immigrants from the East Coast, etc., that are dying in Oregon because of their atrocious driving habits and then complaining because those strait-laced non-scofflaws are getting in their way?



    Just wondering.

  • Did you feel that way about Oregonian drivers prior to moving here, or did this feeling that their prudence is annoying only evolve after a couple of years of endless rotaries and unused turn signals?

  • Yeah, kerb. Can't a guy carry a torch for antiquated spelling practices?

  • Eighthman

    "kerb"?!

blog comments powered by Disqus

Tips

The day's most popular stories from Bostonist every evening in your inbox from our newsletter.

About Bostonist

Bostonist is a website about Boston. More

Editor: Matthew Gannon

Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

nice
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Bostonist.

All Our RSS