Shepard Fairey: Copyright Hypocrite

Yes, we thought we'd done our last Shepard Fairey post of the month, too. But that was before it came to our attention, via Dan Kennedy, our favorite Northeastern prof, that Shepard Fairey might be a little less than consistent when it comes to his reading of copyright law. The street artist, who faces a legal battle with the Associated Press over the photo of Barack Obama that he "referenced" to make his iconic Obama "Hope" poster, has sent his own cease-and-desist letter to Baxter Orr, an Austin, Texas artist who has made a derivative work that pokes fun at Fairey's trademark "Obey Giant." So it's Obey what I say, not what I do? Copylefters, can you still justify this guy? [Dan Wasserman]

Contact the author of this article or email tips@bostonist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Wow!!...Really nice!
    The topic contains some good & interesting news.
    They are informative & valuable. I have also read some news from another website like this.
    Thanks a lot to the authority & wishes their better luck.
  • Good post… Just killing some time at work surfing the interweb and found your post. Great looking website. I will hve to bookmark your blog to come back and see what’s new.
    bioenergoterapeuta Chicago
  • Good post… Just killing some time at work surfing the interweb and found your post. Great looking website. I will hve to bookmark your blog to come back and see what’s new.
    bioenergoterapeuta Chicago
  • Good post… Just killing some time at work surfing the interweb and found your post. Great looking website. I will hve to bookmark your blog to come back and see what’s new. bioenergoterapeuta Chicago
  • Arizona workers comp insurance rates are increasing! Get a quote at
    Arizona Workers Compensation insurance

    Then order some great food from
    Scottsdale Catering

    Phoenix Catering

    Tucson Catering
  • Synchro34
    Great very informative.

    Elektrikli Süpürge Toz Torbası
  • Synchro34
    Very informative blog posts..

    Granite Countertops Pittsburgh
  • honeystewe
    i am very impressed with your lovely  post.. i am so glad to left comment on this..this has been a so interesting read, would love to read more here....
    fine hotel
  • moonkhan
    wow such a nice and good info being continue here,,as well as also you are providing good work,,and i will must say its just due to yours all the efforts and hard work which can be seen here..good work,,good luck..:)
    the celeb
  • Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts.Thank you for sharing great information to us.granite countertops rockville md
  • Great efforts! this post is helpful for me thanks for this information.
    granite countertops rockville md
  • I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains
    wonderful and helpful posts. I have read most of them and got a lot from them.
    To me, you are doing the great work. Carry on. I would like to thank you for
    making such a nice website.
  • Jhon mgt
    Man, that was a really well written article. By the way, where did you get your theme? It looks like it was professionally designed. 

    PIC16F877
  • hajhouj11
    Very informative post.,yes,very useful tips are provided here. thank you so much. Keep up the good works.  iphone 6 <h1><a<br>href="http://www.asseenontvbazar.com...">as seen on tv
    store</a<br></h1>
  • sufi sufi
    Hi there, I found your website via Google even as searching for a similar topic, your web site got here up, it seems to be good. I have bookmarked to my favourites|added to bookmarks.you also bookmark mine
    taj mahal hotel india|gate way of india
  • Its good idea for you. 

    Cheap Weddings Cyprus
  • dsfs
  • Vitali Kuhharev
    If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. ivian sarcos
  • Bryan Lee
    With havin so much content do you ever run into any issues of plagorism or copyright vioelent? My blog has a lot of unique content I've either written myself or outsourced but it seems a lot of it is popping it up all over the web without my permission. Do you know any ways to help prevent content from being stolen? I'd really appreciate it.

    atlanta
    property management
  • every one can share your information ..
    http://flyadvisors.com/
  • come for informatiom..
    http://flyinsurance.blogspot.c...
  • Hea
    Have you Considered Adding videos to your blog readers to keep the more entertained? I just read-through the post and It Was quite good ... inversion tables
  • Ris
    Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. It contains truly information. remote control duplicator
  • You
    have shared a nice blog. I really want ot say you thanks for sharing this nice
    article with us. This one is enlightened blog post. Thanks a lot for sharing
    your valuable views through this blog. I bared so recurrent fascinating stuff
    in blog. real resume help
  • Cyn
    Great information, I value all of these opinions. Everyone needs to feel free to express themselves freely. kennels
  • Alf
    Really impressed! Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. It contains truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing. Looking forward to more! U2 Tribute Band
  • Jhon mgt
    If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.  Beauty coupon code      7

  • kellypelly
    Finally I found something useful to me. I have been looking for information on this particular topic for a lot of time now.
    I can't believe it is this difficult to find something on the Internet.
    I must be looking for the wrong thing or I don't know how to use the computer. Anyway,
    did you know that a quiz consists quiz questions Quizvragen. Therefore you should better start the quiz right now.
  • Rod
    very useful tips are provided here. thank you so much. Keep up the good works.  iphone 6
  • Lyn
    Always remember that powerful words will not only beautify your contents but, they will help you in standing out of the mob . iPad 3
  • wirelesshomesecuritysystems
    Very informative post. I have been searching for information on how to use CSS to display rating stars. I need to use it to improve my tattoo supplies site. wireless home security systems do it yourself
  • Anna
    Thanks. I congratulate you for this blog. I've really enjoyed. I sincerely thank you again.

    _____________________
    buy twitter followers
    get twitter followers
  • moonaseo
    It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your
    excellent post here. I like them very much. I can feel that you paid much
    attention to those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful.
    Thanks so much for sharing.  bad credit payday loans
  • You're so intelligent and very fearless of expressing your points of view. This is really a good read for me, that you were able to elaborate things on the practical side. What you did here was really a tough job which involves practicality.
  • Anna
    Nice information. Its usefulness and significance is overwhelming the way you
    covered all the basic necessary information is really impressive, good work
    keep it up.

    _________________________
    buy youtube views
  • dream summerfield
    I learned lot of stuff in here..great blog post guys!:-)
    grenson
  • I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!…

    lowongan kerja
  • Anna
    It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your
    excellent post here. I like them very much. I can feel that you paid much
    attention to those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful.
    Thanks so much for sharing.

    ______________________
    buy facebook likes
  • Please keep them coming. Greets !This is a in fact good read for me, Must admit that you are human being of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative article.

    naruto and sasuke
  • watch free movies online and get updated whats new on the cinema.. http://cenima1.com
  • Excellent post. Hopefully all of your post on this site are this good. Thanksarthritis remedies
  • Excellent posting. Undoubtedly you are an expert when it comes to this writing. This is absolutely the first time I visited your site and to tell the truth it succeeds in making jobsuche visit here now and then.
  • Salhtun
    I can see that you are putting a lots of efforts into your blog. Keep posting the good work.Some really helpful information in there.backlinks
  • I am Luisa from the builders sydney site, I think the word hypocrite is like a built-in part on a computer. It's an attitude which is from within and it can't be taken from you.
  • I just started posting comments for blog and facing problem of lots of
    rejections. I think your suggestion would be helpful for me. I will let
    you know if its work for me too. Thanks for sharing.
    Isopure
  • ali shass
    I have to say, your blog needs to be one of the best written blogs that I have learn in a protracted time.What I wouldn't give as a way to put up posts which might be as interesting| as yours. 
    White Gold Diamond Earrings
  • ali shass
    I honestly believe there is a skill to writing articles that only very few posses and honestly you got it. The combining of demonstrative and upper-class content is by all odds super rare with the astronomic amount of blogs on the cyberspace. Used Ski Boats

  • ali shass
    The beauty of these blogging engines and CMS platforms is the lack of limitations and ease of manipulation that allows developers to implement rich content and skin the site in such a way that with very little effort one would never notice what it is making the site tick all without limiting content and effectiveness.

    Used Airstream


  • ali shass
    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. 
    Sport Bike Helmet
  • ali shass
    If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. Miami Rhinoplasty
  • ali shass
    All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information. Keep updating, looking forward for more posts. Thanks. Baitcasting Reels
  • ali shass
    Many thanks for making the sincere effort to explain this. I feel fairly strong about it and would like to read more. If it's OK, as you find out more in depth knowledge, would you mind writing more posts similar to this one with more information? 
    Adult Day Care Miami
  • ali shass
    I am very enjoyed for this side. Its a nice topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. I think it may be help all of you. Thanks, Acoustic Violin

  • Thanks for putting this up. Really helpful in creating backlinks! I appreciate it and I am sure everyone else does as well.
    Venta de Tapetes
  • This articles hits the nail right on the head.
    Vote Bookmarks
  • I feel that Orr's parody is a better example of "fair use" than Fairey's posters.
    Social Blare
  • Very good info that is presented in this post. I prefer to read this kind of stuff.Thanks for your kind support.
    Bookmarking Submission
  • Really ,new and more different post/article,,i likes your whole post,thanks for share this with us…
    Free Bookmarks
  • I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs

    Premium Sites
  • This is a unique blog that I will take note of. I already bookmarked it for future reference. Thank you..
    Cool Bookmarks
  • Thanks for putting this up. Really helpful in creating backlinks! I appreciate it and I am sure everyone else does as well.
    Online Bookmarks
  • HAha love this too many people are hypocrites now. We need more quality
    people stepping up in this world. This articles hits the nail right on
    the head.
    Bookmarks Online
  • ali shass
    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

    supergrow laser
  • ali shass
    as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. yritysrekisteri
  • ali shass
    want to say your article is stunning. The lucidity in your post is simply striking and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your rss feed to keep up to date with incoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the delightful work. Tango dresses Toronto
  • My Days at gold coast builders was great just like reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he enjoyed it as well
  • I enjoy my daily experiences in job, reading this one would somehow help my creative writing abilities. You have inspired me to start my own Blog Engine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.keep on posting such an interesting post.
  • I'm going to bookmark on it. because I want to keep browsing there and collect useful info there.!!

    negozio strumenti musicali
  • Hi there! I simply wish to give a huge thumbs up for the great data you
    may have here on this post. I will be coming back to your weblog for
    more soon.
    Top Bookmarks




  • larrzz0jh
    I just started posting comments for blog and facing problem of lots of rejections. I think your suggestion would be helpful for me. I will let you know if its work for me too. Thanks for sharing.
    Sinus headache symptoms
  • Michael Crigs
    Comment by media job; Excellent posting. Undoubtedly you are an expert when it comes to this writing. This is absolutely the first time I visited your site and to tell the truth it succeeds in making me visit here now and then.
  • I am really not too familiar with this subject but I do like to visit blogs for layout ideas. You really expanded upon a subject that I usually don’t care much about and made it very exciting. This is a unique blog that I will take note of. I already bookmarked it for future reference. Thank you..
    cudo Gold Coast is a good example
  • Since when was anybody involved in politics 100 percent honest and almost sin-free (for lack of a better term)..
  • Marc Azada
    Thank you for another great article. Where

    else could anyone find this kind of

    information in such a perfect way of

    writing? Great post!
  • larrzz0jh
    I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he enjoyed it as well
     
    Tedswoodworking
  • flyingfish30
    Copyright is the legal protection of the name of the brand while brand name is the name that you chose and was approved by the copyright body.http://www.satellitedirectsoft.org
  • Hmmm... my first reply did not show up at first. Excuse the two replies.

  • You are aware that Orr is still selling his parody? Fairey dropped the issue because 1.) it made him look like a hypocrite 2.) he knew he did not have a case. It is a good example of "fair use" since Orr created 'Protect' as a parody of Obey Giant and as a social comment about Shepard Fairey's status-- and hype.



  • Square Zero, it might be good for you to know what you are talking about before commenting. There is "fair use" under both copyright and trademark law. Shepard Fairey knows this-- he has used trademarked logos in his work as parody.



    Here is my take on the Baxter Orr / Shepard Fairey issue:



    http://www.myartspace.com/blog/2009/02/fair-use-shepard-fairey-and-baxter-orr.html



    I feel that Orr's parody is a better example of "fair use" than Fairey's posters.

  • square zero

    Balhatain, the fair use exception is far narrower with trademarks that it is with copyrights (check here for an explanation). Baxter and Shepard Fairey are in pretty much the same business -- that makes proving fair use much more difficult (imagine if Coke release a soft drink a parody of the Pepsi logo for a label).

  • You do realize that Baxter Orr is still selling his parody of Obey Giant? Fairey backed off because it made him look like a hypocrite and pointed out contradictions that have shadowed his career. My guess is that he realized he did not have a case. After all, Orr's poster is a good example of parody as well as a social comment about Shepard Fairey's status-- and hype.

  • K F
    HAha love this too many people are hypocrites now. We need more quality people stepping up in this world. This articles hits the nail right on the head.
    How to build a boat
  • square zero

    Just read through the whole Austin Chronicle article and noticed the date. Doesn't mean he didn't have a case. Also, it doesn't change the fact that protecting a trademark is not the same thing as protecting a copyright -- though perhaps you are right that it made him look like a hypocrite (regardless of whether the label is justified).

  • Look up Tom Forsythe vs. Mattel. In that case the judge sided with the artist. The court found that it is important to be critique cultural icons. Obey Giant is a cultural icon, is it not? That does not mean that it is written in stone-- still, don't think for a second that a trademark is off limits.

  • square zero

    Balhatain, my point is not that there are no fair-use exemptions in trademark law, but that the requirements for the fair use of a trademark are different from those of a copyrighted work. The Tom Forsythe vs Mattel case involved parties in different areas of commerce (Forsythe was not making dolls for sale, after all, he was taking photographs). Whether something is a "cultural icon" is not enough; to be granted fair use you have to prove that market confusion is unlikely.



    BTW, my studio just did the graphics for Trojan Barbie at the ART, and we certainly took advantage of the Forsythe decision.

  • Rick Sawyer

    I do know the difference between a trademark and a copyright. It doesn't change the fact that the original Obey Giant image was itself swiped from a copyrighted source and that the C&D letter is evidence that Fairey is more interested in turning a buck than in artistic expression.



    When you start comparing supposed artworks to the logo of Coke or Pepsi, especially when the artist in question is also a supposed counter-cultural, capitalist critique guy, doesn't it start to feel like bullshit?

  • square zero

    I do know the difference between a trademark and a copyright.

    Not when it comes to the requirements for fair use. For all intents and purposes, Baxter is a competitor in the art marketplace (he sells prints, after all, just like Fairey). As such, the potential for consumer confusion is very high. It doesn't matter that the image has been altered for "satirical" purpose; in fact, that makes it worse, since Fairey is know for doing exactly the same thing. I should add that had the image been published in a magazine as commentary, Baxter would have stood in much firmer ground. Ultimately, the dispute was not about art, but about business (which is why I brought up the Coke/Pepsi issue).



    When you start comparing supposed artworks to the logo of Coke or Pepsi, especially when the artist in question is also a supposed counter-cultural, capitalist critique guy, doesn't it start to feel like bullshit?



    Rick, Fairey is an artist, a graphic designer, and a business man; he makes no bones about it, and his work regularly skirts the edges of all three disciplines. After getting a fair amount of exposure to the contemporary art world, his approach strikes me as refreshingly honest. I think there's plenty of reason to criticize his work (his appropriation of the work of relatively unknown Cuban and Puerto Rican graphic artists, for example), but I just don't think he's a hypocrite.



    I should say that, as the designer for the ICA, I'm not an uninterested party. Still, I feel the issues Fairey raises deserve a bit of nuance.

  • Thanks for putting this up. Really helpful in creating backlinks! I appreciate it and I am sure everyone else does as well.
  • Rick Sawyer

    Square Zero, it is extremely presumptuous for you to declare what I do and do not know about the law. If you noticed, I have refrained from discussing the legal merits of either case. I would suggest that you, as a mere designer, do the same. Nobody, not professors of media law, not lawyers with dozens of copyright litigations under their belt, can say with certainty how these cases will turn out.



    Whatever the legal merits of the case, it is a rather sinister contradiction for a man who has made his livelihood and fame appropriating the work of others (and, as you astutely point out, putting his own brand name on the work of unknown graphic designers) to bring legal action against another artist who does precisely the same thing, whether it's a trademark or a picture of Shepard Fairey's mom. To suggest otherwise is to enter into a discussion of legalistic minutiae that would not withstand other claims that Fairey might make, on the free use of public space, for example. It's extremely craven to hide behind one law, that makes you money, while flaunting others that you find restrictive.



    And, at the very least, it's not very punk rock.

  • square zero

    Square Zero, it is extremely presumptuous for you to declare what I do and do not know about the law.

    Fair enough. Then again, it is also extremely presumptuous of you to declare me a "mere designer" (since you know nothing about my background).



    If you noticed, I have refrained from discussing the legal merits of either case. I would suggest that you, as a mere designer, do the same.

    I wouldn't venture a guess as to how these cases would fare in court (or whether they would even make it there). My point is that for Fairy to protect a business asset (which is what his trademark is) does not necessarily make him a hypocrite in the Obama/AP case. The law that protects his trademark is different from the law that protects the AP's copyrighted work; the two are conceptually, legally, and ethically distinct. It is possible to agree with one and disagree with the other. (Now, where he to bring action against the myriad of Obama/Hope parodies out there, then I would agree that he's a hypocrite.)



    ...it is a rather sinister contradiction for a man who has made his livelihood and fame appropriating the work of others [...] to bring legal action against another artist who does precisely the same thing

    Rick, as you probably know, trademarks are not granted automatically. They are sought, at great expense to the owner. It makes no sense to get one if you do not intend to protect it (in fact, a trademark can be lost if not defended). You can certainly argue that for Fairey to seek trademark status for his version of the Andre image is "a sinister contradiction"; threatening legal action against a trademark infringer seems to me perfectly consistent. (Besides, as I argued above, what Baxter Orr did with the Andre image is not "precisely the same thing," legally or ethically, as what Fairey did with the AP photo.)



    And, at the very least, it's not very punk rock.

    At the risk of once again being presumptuous, if you actually believe that statement, you really know nothing about punk rock. (Read up on Malcolm McLaren, for starters.)

  • Rick Sawyer

    Fair enough. Then again, it is also extremely presumptuous of you to declare me a "mere designer" (since you know nothing about my background).



    Missed this part. Most definitely.

  • Rick Sawyer

    I think that it would be fair to say that Malcolm McLaren and I are operating with a different definition of punk rock.



    I continue to disagree that these cases are "conceptually, legally, and ethically distinct," and, if they are, it doesn't let Fairey off the hook for being a hypocrite.



    Conceptually: Andre the Giant was a trademark of WWF (now WWE) that Fairey swiped, used for years to establish his name, and, finally, transformed into his own logo, absent the word "Giant," which the WWF refused to let him use. Where's he getting off coming down on a fellow artist who's trying the same gambit? It's a power play, pure and simple.



    Not only that, in my mind, as a spectator, the "OBEY" logo compromises Fairey's art to an absurd degree. As gifted as he is with color, or as a designer, I can't look at his prints without honing in on "OBEY," and cringing. I don't like feeling like I've been cheated. I guess Fairey and McLaren have more in common than I have with either of them.



    Legally: I'd point out that the C&D letter invoked 17 U.S.C. 101, the chapter on copyright, and not 15 USC, which is the section on trademark. The trademark argument is not one that Fairey or his lawyers were making, so you might be more productive lambasting them, rather than underpaid bloggers, about the difference between trademark and copyright.



    Moreover, fair use, as a concept, can be applied to trademarks, just as it can be to copyrighted works. And the irony that OBEY Giant, itself, is a derivation of a trademark does not bode well for your case against hypocrisy.



    Ethically: It's not like Orr set out to trick people into thinking that he had a line of skating gear, hipster apparel, and "information about rebellious teen lifestyle activities" (that last bit from the actual "Obey" trademark), which would be a more ethically nefarious purpose than simply making fun of Fairey, his artwork, and his nauseating self-importance, which is the sort of thing that a younger Fairey would be down with. That's the strong case for trademark over copyright, after all, and I see no reason why somebody would confuse Orr's poster with Fairey's Obey empire.

  • square zero

    That's the strong case for trademark over copyright, after all, and I see no reason why somebody would confuse Orr's poster with Fairey's Obey empire.



    I actually do see a potential for confusion, particularly once the poster goes out into the wild, as it were, without Orr's attribution. But, if you are right that Fairey's lawyers sought a copyright claim -- rather than a trademark claim -- then his action is certainly inconsistent (and makes my point kind of moot).



    As gifted as he is with color, or as a designer, I can't look at his prints without honing in on "OBEY," and cringing.

    For better or for worse, that reaction if very much in line with Fairey's project (as I understand it).

  • square zero

    It might be a good idea for you (and Dan Wasserman) to look up the difference between a trademark and a copyright -- they aren't the same thing, though sometimes people use the terms interchangeably. Fairey is not being hypocritical, though the accusation sure makes good copy.

  • is among the. a great deal of I really just wanted It is refreshing to find people who write like they know what they are talking about rhondaallison.com

  • Hello dudesi enjoy the blogs entries from this webpage. i have made my own.. come check my website out some time watch movies jan marini cream

  • hi,I just thought you might want to know that your blog lookslicensed mortgage bankers li ny epicuren cleansern

  • Great to become browsing your blog once more, it continues to be months for me. Properly this write-up that ive been waited for so lengthy. I will need this write-up to total my assignment inside the college, and it has exact same subject together with your article. Thanks, great share. claytonshagal.com

blog comments powered by Disqus

Tips

The day's most popular stories from Bostonist every evening in your inbox from our newsletter.

About Bostonist

Bostonist is a website about Boston. More

Editor: Matthew Gannon

Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

nice
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Bostonist.

All Our RSS