The Boston Globe Explains Hipsters, Haters

Our buddies at The Boston Globe have championed another investigative reporting win, one that will surely put the newspaper back on top of the media market. Fashion writer Christopher Muther wrote a little piece on a curious subculture whose followers ride fixies, wear ironic t-shirts, and love Grizzly Bear. That's right, hipsters. Though Muther admits that hipsters have been around for a little while and are basically unavoidable today, his investigative skills need a little retuning. Muther is one of many who consider hipsters to be a relatively newfound subculture, in that it has only existed this decade. In reality, hipsters have been around since the dawn of the teenager, but in different names. Be it the beats, hippies, punks, grunge kids, each of these subcultures were overrun with youth chasing their impression of cool, and in essence trying to be "hip." The only notable thing about hipsters today is that there is no unique nomenclature to separate them from decades past, and have thus been relegated to the blanket terms of hipsters, scenesters, and even indie kid.

Muther goes on to explain the reason hipsters have become magnets for hatred today. The economy:

Back in the capricious days of Fantasia Barrino and Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights, people didn’t mind these ironic Peter Pans extending their youth by leeching off their parents and gentrifying entire neighborhoods. Now, their antics seem, well, annoying.

In all honesty, that description sounds just as annoying at any period of time as it does now. Economy be damned, but hating on people chasing cool without caring about the subculture has always existed. Perhaps this Bostonist is just upset because he has been hating on hipsters before it was cool.

Email This Entry


Comments (5) [rss]

user-pic

At the risk of exposing my utter ignorance of hipsterism, I'd have never thought Fantasia Barrino and Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights occupy a significant place in hipster lore. Frankly, I'd have never linked Fantasia Barrino and Dirty Dancing: Havana Nights in any context except that they apparently happened in 2004.

Yeah, I have to concur with you on the Fantasia Barrino/Dirty Dancing thing. I think that was Muther's clever attempt at placing the quintisential hipster's ironic love of bad pop culture phenomena as a means of pointing out the year. But to be honest, I've also never heard of hipsters ironically fawning over Fantasia or Dirty Dancing. I think Muther may have anachronistically placed the love of irony in the wrong frame of pop culture, or at least name checked the wrong things whatsoever... it's also confusing as, in the article, Muther mentions that the hipster's love of irony tends to extend to pop culture events and trends that have occured in decades past, so even his idea to point out a date with the use of a person or film doesn't really work... at least that's what I think... Really, that's just another notch in why that quote is so absurd.

people have complained about hipsters since the dawn of time, and will continue to do so until the last trucker hat has been burned to ash and scattered on the hipsterless winds. maybe it is a little more frustrating to deal with rich kids dressing poor when the stock market's decline has made you a little more poor yourself, but that's just another case of poor-rich-me-ism-ness at work.

and by the extraordinarily incoherent phrase "poor-rich-me-ism-ness" i mean rich people feeling sorry for themselves because they can only afford to eat lunch on newbury street three times a week instead of five. (see also http://bostonist.com/2009/03/02/some_people_have_been_working_your.php.)

Huh... and here I though hipsterdom would survive a nuclear armageddon... though you never know what's trendy among roaches.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

The day's most popular stories from Bostonist every evening in your inbox from our newsletter.

About Bostonist

Bostonist is a website about Boston. More

Editors: Rick and Kerry

Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Keeping Quail up in Maine: http://www.pawesome.net/2010/08/a-tale-of-maine-quail/
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Bostonist.

All Our RSS